CI posted a comment on a story that I’m not sure how many have seen. It’s a local story, but in many ways I think it encapsulates a lot of what is wrong with the national left as we look to the incipient cluster-shtup that will result from the Democrat-controlled congress.
It’s the tale of a poor black woman named Taylor Frazier McCollum who became the key figure in stopping a $5 billion data center that was set to be built on 80 acres in Maryland. As such, it had all the makings of a great just-so story for the left.
[Full Disclosure: I am no expert on Data Centers, and would not argue that they are cost-free, and should be supported everywhere and in all contexts. But I think the opposite argument is equally absurd.]
The data center was going to be built on 80 acres of pristine, environmentally sensitive forests, thus angering Gaia, the Sierra Club, and Elizabeth Warren, whose warrior ancestors once hunted those sacred lands with their locally grown, green, net-zero and gluten-free bows and arrows. (#wemustneverstopmockingher)
Wait a second. My crack research team informs me that the 80 acres were actually a desolate, concrete-covered wasteland that had been home to the Landover Mall. (And also that Liz Warren’s ancestors were the whitest of white Europeans, who made Tom Petty look like John Lee Hooker. Which reminds me, you could do a lot worse on a Monday morning than to listen to Petty’s “Shadow of a Doubt” and Hooker’s “Whiskey and Wimmen,” back to back. Somehow, “she always keeps me guessin’…she’s a complex kid” seems to go well with “Whiskey and women almost wrecked my life/ Weren’t for whiskey and women I’d have money today.”)
Where was I? Oh yeah. So the 80 acres had housed a closed down mall. Big deal. The mall had probably shut down six months ago, so maybe if the locals could have had a little more time, a new business might have gone in there. Probably a local business, selling locally sourced, organic and gluten-free stuff. But no, Big Data had to rush in there before any other businesses could make a better offer—
Hold on. My team has just informed me that the mall closed down 24 YEARS AGO. I really should have looked into the details before I started writing.
But that fact does explain the picture showing a landscape of broken up concrete with what looks like weeds big enough to provide some nice shade on a hot day. Seriously. These look like the majestic redwoods of the weed world. (Note to self: I know that old-growth forests exist, so research whether there’s such a thing as old-growth weeds.)
Anyway I’m sure Taylor is well-informed on development issues, or at least has acquainted herself with the basic facts about data centers—
Hang on. Fool me twice, shame on you, but fool me thrice, and I’m going to be looking like Jazzy Crockett over here. So let me just check my facts…
Annnnnddddd…Taylor knows as much about data centers as I know about what “gluten free” means. But don’t take my word for it. Listen to her reaction when she first heard about the planned data center:
“I was like, ‘Oh, hell no. Why would you want to bring water-polluting, diesel-generating data centers right down the street from where people live, work, play?”
Um. Who’s going to tell her that data centers don’t pollute water, and they don’t generate any diesel? (Although that last part would be pretty cool, since diesel is expensive, and we could use more of it.)
Look, I don’t want to pile on and make fun of Taylor McCollum. She’s the little guy in this drama, and she’s been badly misinformed. A woman on Dave Rubin’s podcast described her with a euphemism that I am going to use from now on: “pre-informed.” (Which sounds so much better than “ignorant and wrong.”)
And she has her own problems. She’s got a daughter with no husband in the picture, and has struggled financially to the point of being evicted from an apartment and having to couch-surf with friends and relatives. She has unpaid debts and unpaid parking tickets. She doesn’t know anything about the cause she’s chosen to protest, and she’s apparently absorbed the toxic victim mentality that the left is always selling.
She said, “I created the ideal life paying for us to live in this apartment and have our own space…and then to have it taken away.”
Sweetheart, it wasn’t taken away from you. You signed a contract promising to pay rent, and when you stopped doing that, you were evicted. That’s how life works. As a landlord, if my tenants stop paying me and I don’t replace them with tenants who will, I will soon have my house “taken away” from me by Chase Bank. And I wouldn’t be the victim in that situation.
You won’t be surprised to know that NPR and MSNOW portrayed her story as a righteous grass-roots campaign, with her playing David to the data center’s Goliath. But when Reason and Legal Insurrection (among others) investigated, they found that her petition had less than a couple of hundred signers before a far-left group connected to far-left billionaire Neville Roy Singham funded the effort, which then took off.
In other words, it’s one more leftist “grass roots” campaign that turned out to be astroturf. Not to mention doomed to eventual failure, since it is crossways with reality in the way that most leftist economic crusades are.
To their credit, even NPR’s story doesn’t avoid mentioning the seeds of disaster that McCollum’s tragically successful anti-data center campaign has planted. They admit that now that the county has decided to protect the non-profit “Busted Concrete and Redwood Weed Preserve,” some locals “worry about declining tax revenue.” Also, “The county faces a budget deficit.”
UNEXPECTEDLY!
Taylor McCollom has moved on, though. She appeared at a recent council meeting to push a new project: advocating for taxpayer funds for roof repairs. Coincidentally enough, her grandpa’s home – where she is living in lieu of providing her own shelter – needs roof repairs.
Gee, if only there were some gigantic local development that would be pouring huge amounts of money into the community, some of which might be skimmed off by homeless local activists who don’t support themselves and are in need of, oh, I don’t know…roofing nails, and roofing paper, and roof flashing, and shingles.
All of which – I’m just guessing here – are very likely gluten free.
I said above that I think McCollum’s story is emblematic of a problematic pattern on the left. Because she is a non-threatening figure who can be painted as a kind of everywoman. She is black and female, which in leftist iconography means that she is sympathetic and noble. (If she were a conservative black female, she’d have both her blackness and femaleness called into question, and be called the female equivalent of an Uncle Tom. An “Aunt Thomasina,” I guess.)
She can be coopted as a positive figurehead behind whom wealthy leftist groups can hide, and when the leftist plan’s “success” creates even more difficulties for her, she will become perpetually dependent, and thus a supporter of future leftist plans to rescue her from the failures that their plans created.
She has also been funded by leftist group grants to help metastasize the extreme anti-data center fight all over the place, including to Atlanta, Memphis and even Zambia.
Which I imagined has prompted many Zambians to say whatever is Zambianese for, “WTF is this woman doing? What has Zambia ever done to her? We don’t expect data centers to solve all of our problems, but we’re living in mud huts and burning dung for warmth over here. If a data center could bring us any kind of development or resources, I will name my next child Data Center Makimbo!”
I see her as having many parallels to AOC. McCollum’s origin story – as a grassroots hero who despite her poverty and lack of support managed to stop a giant corporation from filling her community’s streets with a toxic mixture of polluted water and diesel fuel – was a lie.
Similarly, AOC’s origin story – as a tough Latina from the Bronx who overcame her hardscrabble background and used her meager bartender’s earnings to self-fund a long-shot congressional campaign and rise to the heights of power – is a lie. She went by “Sandy” and was raised in tony Westchester, with an architect father who founded his own firm, and while she touts her small donors and lack of corporate funding, she has an estimated $20 million war chest funded mostly through opaque streams of PAC and interest group money.
And just like McCollum prevented a water-polluting, diesel-spewing data center from coming into her community, AOC prevented a $2.5 billion Amazon HQ and the 25,000 jobs it would have brought with it, from coming into her district.
She celebrated when Amazon went elsewhere – possibly Zambia – making public statements suggesting that she wrongly believes that the tax incentives Amazon would have received were actually payments that New York taxpayers would have given to Amazon.
What can you say about a gal like that?
I mean, other that she is EXTREMELY pre-informed.
Hamas (and the DSA) delenda est.
0-0-0
If you enjoyed this column, please share it and the Cautious Intelligence site. Also, click Subscribe (on the bottom of your phone screen, or the right side of your computer screen) to receive a notice when new columns post here.